GambleFiHub / Insights

Novig Sues Ohio, 45 Days After Its Cease-and-Desist

Bar chart of days after Novig's first suit on 4 August 2026: New York day 0, Washington, Massachusetts and New Mexico day 2, Wisconsin day 10, Missouri day 73, Arkansas day 100 and Ohio day 104 (highlighted)

Novig has taken Ohio to federal court. Ludlow Exchange, LLC, which trades as Novig, filed a 53-page complaint in the Northern District of Ohio on 16 November 2026 against Attorney General Andy Wilson, interim executive director Andromeda Morrison and the seven members of the Ohio Casino Control Commission (docket 1:26-cv-03009, complaint). It wants a court order that stops Ohio from enforcing its gambling laws against the sports event contracts Novig lists as a CFTC-designated contract market. The case is assigned to Judge Charles Esque Fleming.

The letter behind the suit

On 2 October Morrison wrote that Novig is “operating online sports gaming” and is “clearly engaged in bookmaking or facilitating bookmaking in violation of Ohio civil and criminal law”. It gave the exchange 14 days to confirm in writing that it had stopped, and warned of “administrative, civil, nuisance, or criminal actions”. The letter relied on the Sixth Circuit’s 25 September ruling in KalshiEX v. Schuler. The complaint says the Commission also asked for a $5 million penalty against Kalshi in an administrative case in April, and on 20 October told its own licensees to stop serving unlicensed exchanges, as covered in our report on that letter.

Two claims, one familiar

The first count is the Commerce Clause argument Polymarket US used when it sued Ohio on 16 October. Ohio licences online sportsbooks only for businesses with an Ohio presence or a deal with an Ohio proprietor, caps proprietors at 25, and requires the servers that accept wagers to be in the state. Novig says that would split up the national pool of buyers and sellers its order book needs. The second count is preemption: Novig says its contracts are swaps under the CFTC’s exclusive jurisdiction. It argues that Schuler “is not final”, because Kalshi’s petition for rehearing en banc has been pending since 9 October, and that the CFTC’s 9 October event-contract rules changed the ground the ruling stood on. Novig asks for preliminary and permanent injunctions and a declaratory judgment.

Key facts

Case: Ludlow Exchange, LLC d/b/a Novig v. Wilson et al., N.D. Ohio No. 1:26-cv-03009, filed 16 Nov 2026.
Judge: Charles Esque Fleming; related case flagged: Underdog Exchange DCM v. Wilson, No. 1:26-cv-02169.
Counts: Commerce Clause; preemption under the Commodity Exchange Act.
Relief sought: preliminary and permanent injunctions, declaratory judgment.
Exchange: CFTC-designated contract market since 16 June 2026.
Status: complaint and summonses filed on 16 Nov; no injunction motion on the docket yet.

Our numbers

Novig sued 45 days after the letter, 31 days after its 14-day deadline ran out; Polymarket US filed on day 14. Of the 10 companies Ohio wrote to on 2 October, five have stopped offering new sports contracts in the state, the Commission told Legal Sports Report: Plus500US, Moomoo, Robinhood, Gemini and Coinbase. Two are now suing, Polymarket US and Novig, and Underdog has fought Ohio in its own case since 8 September. That leaves ProphetX and Webull, the two still listed as in talks. On CourtListener, the Ohio case is Novig’s eighth district-court suit against a state in 104 days: five in the first ten days of August (New York, Washington, Massachusetts, New Mexico, Wisconsin), then Missouri on day 73, Arkansas on day 100 and Ohio on day 104 (see chart). The Massachusetts case was stayed in August at both sides’ request.

Why it matters for GambleFi

The timing is the story. Novig filed six days after a Manhattan judge ruled that its sports contracts are not swaps, a ruling it has appealed to the Second Circuit, and it is now asking a court inside the Sixth Circuit, where Schuler already went against Kalshi, to reach the opposite result. That fits the pattern from Missouri: sue before the state does. It also comes as nine senators press the CFTC to drop its push against geoblocking. Onchain sports books such as SX Bet have no federal licence to point to at all; the GambleFi FAQ explains how prediction markets differ from crypto casinos. This is a report on a court filing, not legal or betting advice.

18+

Gamble responsibly

Gambling can be addictive and may cause financial harm. Crypto assets can also be volatile and lose value.

If gambling is causing problems, seek support from a responsible gambling organisation in your region.